[Wilshire]

If nothing else, every Inchoroi that we have seen must have had a soul as the entire species went through the sorcery-graphing. All the ones that failed, died, and all the ones that succeeded went on to carry the war forward.

Sorcery Graphting might have been a forceful addition of a soul into a un-souled vessel, rather than something genetic like we usually assume. Though, this doesn't seem terribly likely given that I'm pretty sure the IF was used to keep the Inchoroi in line through the eons.

[H]

Though, this doesn't seem terribly likely given that I'm pretty sure the IF was used to keep the Inchoroi in line through the eons.

I think this is likely the best evidence that all Inchoroi were souled.  Because they were specifically made to work toward the end of saving the Progenitor's souls, with the goad of saving their own.  Would not make much sense for them to not have any then.

[SmilerLoki]

Though, this doesn't seem terribly likely given that I'm pretty sure the IF was used to keep the Inchoroi in line through the eons.

I think this is likely the best evidence that all Inchoroi were souled.  Because they were specifically made to work toward the end of saving the Progenitor's souls, with the goad of saving their own.  Would not make much sense for them to not have any then.

I concur.

[Khaine]

Maybe this has been raised elsewhere, but what happened to the progenitors?

Do we know? Were they riding along in the Ark and died during the fall?

Were they already dead when the mad quest for salvation started?

Is there another thread on this issue? I tried to search the word progenitor but I got no hits.

[H]

Maybe this has been raised elsewhere, but what happened to the progenitors?

Do we know? Were they riding along in the Ark and died during the fall?

Were they already dead when the mad quest for salvation started?

Is there another thread on this issue? I tried to search the word progenitor but I got to hits.

Unfortunately we must keep the posts brief at the moment, but the short answer, I think, is no, we don't know what happened to them.

Personally, I think they were on board Ark, because it just makes more sense to me.  One, it can be a call to something like Noah's Arc, and two, if Ark succeeded, what good would that do the Progenitors on the other side of the galaxy?  I don't buy the notion, personally, of a Universal Outside, even though I do think an Outside is Universal.